Natan
Contrarian Stock Investor
PayPal has proven a bad investment, and capital is better used in TransMedics and PROCEPT BioRobotics, whose valuations make no sense given how well their businesses are performing. Valuation models give PayPal about 40% upside versus over 100% for the other two, and no catalysts are in sight to take PayPal to $80. x.com x.com x.comÂ
PayPal's cost cuts and reserve releases prop up short-term numbers, while investing for growth wastes time. Its slow bleed gives delusional bulls hope, making it the ultimate value trap; it should not be a public company. x.comÂ
PayPal's near-flat growth and rising checkout competition leave it a Grade C, prove-it story. Q3 FY26 revenue rose just 2%; operating income fell 8% as restructuring charges rose from $69 million to $255 million, and net income fell 14%. The business still earns over $1 billion a quarter, but it is treading water. x.comÂ
PayPal's raised earnings and free-cash-flow guidance supports rejecting Stripe and Advent's $60.50-per-share offer. The shares now trade around $57, below the rejected bid, but that does not make the rejection a mistake. x.comÂ
PayPal's growth has stalled and it faces too much fintech competition. That view could change if the company adapts, pivots and proves otherwise. x.comÂ
PayPal is a value trap with a great story until a real catalyst appears. At about 8x forward earnings it is near a decade low and cheaper than JPMorgan, but cheapness has been the thesis for two years while it kept getting cheaper. A re-rating needs a trigger: a buyer, a turn in Venmo monetization, or price carving a higher low to prove the bleed is over. x.comÂ
PayPal's downside finally looks done after a 10-year round trip, leaving the stock undervalued at a P/E of 8 and a PEG ratio of 0.8. A solid Q2 report could start a recovery back to $60+. x.comÂ
PayPal faces structural disintermediation as agentic commerce and ecosystem wallets like Apple Pay and Google Pay erode its role as a checkout intermediary. Branded checkout grew just 1.0% in Q4 2025, a sign it is losing the buy button, despite over $6B of annual free cash flow. CEO Enrique Lores is pivoting to agentic infrastructure with ChatGPT, but with a $9B refinancing looming, PayPal looks a value trap until AI-first growth outpaces Apple and Google. x.comÂ
PayPal faces an existential competitive threat from X Money, which will kill its business. x.comÂ
PayPal options activity suggests traders are positioning for a longer-term move up, unless it is a hedge, so the stock should recover soon. The war has weighed on the shares. x.comÂ
PayPal is worth over $100 a share, but its current board will not get it there. x.comÂ
