Wayne Liang
Asymmetric Investment Research, Trade Alerts & Toolkits
Apple's 9% drop on weaker guidance is negligible for a long-term holder. It beat earnings, but guidance was hurt by significant DRAM and NAND price inflation and supply constraints, which also suggests the memory supercycle is not over. Apple is one of the names worth holding long term, and Alphabet's earnings gap-down recovered within days. x.com
Apple is a safe haven amid AI-stock volatility and will gain momentum if it persists over the next two weeks through the midterms. New products and another defensive day bring a momentum push toward $358, then $367 in November closer. x.com
Apple's balance sheet and lack of spend keep a bid under its stock whether the market rises or falls. That bid gets stronger with foldable phones that break. x.com
Memory-cost pressure, weak volumes and weak services should make Apple's quarter bad, giving the short a chance to work on this quarter alone. Other hardware companies this quarter also point to weakness, though Apple has been a terrible short so far. x.com x.com
A supply response could compress Western Digital's pricing and margins, eroding its apparent cheapness. Its 2013-24 normalized earnings merit a look: even huge demand growth in other industries eventually drew supply and mediocre returns. A digestion/reset would hurt buy-and-hold investors, though the outcome is uncertain. Pre-AI economics were mediocre and unlikely to become amazing post-AI; TSMC's stronger pre-AI economics make its post-AI case better. x.com x.com x.com
Apple is emerging as Big Tech's safe haven because it is immune to the AI infrastructure spending that has hyperscalers burning cash. Its 10.1x EV/sales valuation is elevated versus history but arguably justified by renewed growth and that immunity. A multi-model signal is very bullish, with all four models risk-on. The one technical wrinkle: a full selloff extension could target $292, so tomorrow's product event risks a sell-the-news replay of February–March. x.com
Apple is a sell here because buybacks are replacing innovation while its share price is dangerously extended. It is not spending on AI, in cloud services, making robots or pursuing global WiFi; its VR, Siri chatbot and iCar efforts have failed. Its flip phone follows Samsung's, and AirPods have poor battery life and microphones. The share price has held up, but only for now. x.com
Apple is increasingly rewarded as a good steward of capital in the AI race, an AI beneficiary and a safe haven from the capex wars. In a recession triggered by an AI bubble popping, Apple would be the ultimate consumer staple and surprise to the upside, potentially scooping up AI infrastructure cheaply and benefiting from local LLMs. x.com
SK hynix's five-year agreements with 14 major customers cover more than half its 2027-28 capacity, giving its memory earnings unusually long visibility. DRAM prices rose 28% and NAND 25% in the quarter, while operating profit reached 62.8 billion against 58.5 billion expected; Q4 DRAM shipments are guided up 25% from Q3. Those commitments support the view that demand is not peaking yet. Overweight, $400 target. x.com
Apple's valuation pays too hefty a premium for its expected long-term earnings growth. Its forward P/E-to-growth ratio is 2.58; even if the market sees its hardware moat and ability to exploit others' AI investments despite underinvesting itself as a winning strategy, that premium is too high. x.com
Apple will keep hitting all-time highs because it makes money off Alphabet and both companies capture a return on that relationship, so negative takes on Siri AI, like @anandragn's, can be ignored. The near term is uncertain. x.com
