European refiners Repsol and OMV offer better risk/reward and could rally sharply if the US imposes export curbs. x.com
Arrakis Global
Global Thematic Fund Manager
Shell's stronger refining profits and larger buyback support the view that its breakout holds. Q3 adjusted earnings reached $10.8 billion versus $9.9 billion expected, as refining margins hit a record $42 a barrel; the three-month buyback rises from $3 billion to $5 billion. Those margins will not last forever. x.com
Money is rotating from big refiners and integrated oil companies into oil drilling and servicing firms. The move could be in its early innings, and the recent drilling gains alongside refiner losses are working in that direction. x.com
Eni is the premier public way to profit from Algeria's insulated pipeline gas exports to Europe if the Strait of Hormuz closes. As the primary foreign partner of Algeria's Sonatrach, it owns irreplaceable Mediterranean infrastructure feeding Europe's structural gas deficit. With a portfolio breakeven below $40 a barrel, price gains from a supply shock drop almost entirely to the bottom line. Risks include European windfall taxes, shifting carbon rules and offshore execution. x.com x.com
Renewed Ukraine and Iran tensions should push oil higher again. The Kobeissi Letter reports a Ukrainian strike on a major Russian oil terminal. Higher oil adds to last week's financing worries; even slight earnings weakness in the next few weeks could be disastrous for markets. A rally at the open would not surprise, though, as headlines shift quickly. x.com
The oil trade is over because crude can no longer make higher highs, even with Middle East crude exports back near their peaks. Oil is trading around its average price of the last eight months and set a lower high in September, so it is only a matter of time before the market gives up. Crude looks about to fall through the floor, with rates following and high-beta stocks then going vertical as every dip gets bought. x.com x.com x.com
US oil stocks have a fantastic long-term picture once Hormuz reopens, as the conflict lifts oil's floor, so any selloff on a US export ban would be a buying opportunity. A WTI-Brent spread that widened from flat to high double digits in two weeks signals a high risk of a ban, more likely on products than crude, which could pull WTI back and hit US names. Value them on long-term free cash flow and growth at $80 oil, with $75 WTI a possible new floor, not on a brief $150-200 spike. x.com
Refiners such as Valero and PBF look past their best, because higher oil prices are no longer necessarily bullish for them. Per a client, refiners are running at 95% and still can't build finished-product inventories. These look like as-good-as-it-gets earnings, and prices look ahead to demand deconstruction: high prices force alternatives and faster cost-cutting. Capacity scarcity still supports valuations, as with AI stocks, but price controls always backfire. x.com x.com x.com
Crude oil now has more room to fall on a deal headline than to rise on the status quo, as Trump's rejection of Iran's seven-day Hormuz plan looks like a negotiating position, with negotiators due back this week and the Saudi foreign minister in Washington. The closed Strait put Brent back at $108 with Nov–Dec backwardation near $8. Speculators added shorts three weeks running, squeeze fuel above $100 if talks fail; a deal would leave about 101,828 contracts of net length as supply. x.com x.com
Refiners such as Valero and Marathon Petroleum may be nearing a top, because the cure for high prices is always high prices. The stocks have made monster moves as crack spreads blow out and foreign buyers fight for distillate capacity. x.com
Oil refiners look too late to chase because they are over-earning, and margins will likely compress down the line. Refiners ran as Chinese utilization fell about 40% and 40% of Russian capacity went offline because of the war, pushing product-versus-crude margins to all-time highs of $80-100. Oil services names such as SLB look better placed to benefit. x.com