Oliver | MMMT Wealth
Founder of MMMT Wealth, CPA, Technical/Fundamental Analysis
Fortinet looks expensive at 48x cash earnings and 40x next year's, versus about 30x for software companies. Fair value is $116-$148, roughly 30x next year's cash earnings give or take 12%, so the stock trades 19% above the top of fair and turns expensive above $196. This is a valuation screen based on reported earnings and revenue estimates, with no deeper fundamental work. x.comÂ
Fortinet's recurring service growth is slowing while its firewall product refresh does the heavy lifting. Service revenue grew 13% versus 37% for products, and the full-year service guide was cut to $5.15-$5.17 billion. A cut to the recurring guide rarely gets bought back in a week; this looks like the start of a rerating lower. x.comÂ
Fortinet is a beautiful business because recurring security subscriptions make it highly stable and cash-generative. It is the clear leader in firewalls, protecting over 800,000 clients with fast, energy-efficient tools built on its own custom chips. x.comÂ
Tenable looks cheap among cybersecurity software names, trading at a lower P/E than Palo Alto Networks and CrowdStrike, a lower forward P/E than Fortinet, and one of the group's lowest PEG ratios. Its chart shows a double breakout from a triangle and range highs, with low cycles and confirming on-balance volume. x.comÂ
Fortinet has topped because large language models will impair its business. x.com x.comÂ
Fortinet's results look excellent and should lift sentiment across security stocks. Its full-year revenue guidance came in about 3% ahead of expectations, with EPS guidance comfortably ahead too. x.comÂ
CrowdStrike's growth is too slow to justify its valuation. Its forward P/E has climbed to about 190, while stock-based compensation exceeds operating earnings, so reported free cash flow margins do not show what the business actually earns. x.com x.com x.com x.comÂ
Palo Alto Networks at 21x forward sales is too expensive for 17% pro-forma growth, despite BTIG's view that it is worth more than the current price. x.comÂ
Fortinet is being welcomed into the portfolio as a new holding. x.comÂ
Palo Alto Networks is the most overvalued cybersecurity stock by a mile, at about 25x forward revenue while growing only 15% organically. Anything above 10x revenue is hard to justify, let alone 20x. Worse, the "Mythos moment" that sent cyber valuations vertical has not yet shown up in its results. x.com x.comÂ